In the summer of my fourth year, I had two companions no one else could see. They were not the wispy figments other children conjure. Darla and Gable were as solid to me as the heat shimmering off the gravel road outside our new house in Dry Springs. Darla wore a faded yellow sundress with a torn hem, and her hair was the color of a dusty sunset. Gable was older, with a sharp jaw and eyes that held a cold, patient fire. They spoke to me in low, conspiratorial tones, filling the long afternoons with games and secrets. My parents, in their gentle, weary way, assumed it was a phase, a way to cope with the move and my father’s new job at the grain elevator. But they never saw Darla point to the rust-red stain on the living room carpet and say, ‘That’s where he bled out.’ They never heard Gable whisper about the old well behind the house, its wooden cover rotted through, and how a child’s scream still echoed there if you listened close.
My most vivid memory is the fire. It happened at my grandmother’s home in Maple Creek, a house smelling of mothballs and cinnamon. I was sitting on the floor, playing with a tin of buttons, when Darla knelt beside me, her face flushed with an excitement I mistook for playful. ‘The old man,’ she said, meaning my grandfather’s brother, who we were visiting, ‘he keeps his secrets in the basement. Behind the furnace. Burn it all away.’ I didn’t question her. I had just discovered the long matches on the mantle, their sulfur heads bright as tiny suns. I struck one, watched it flare, and dropped it into the pile of old newspapers stacked near the basement door. The flames rose with a hungry crackle, and I stood back, feeling a strange pride as Darla nodded from the corner. The adults ran, pulling me outside, but I remember looking back and seeing Gable standing in the kitchen window, his face impassive, as the smoke curled behind him.
After the fire, my parents became more vigilant. They noticed how I would stop mid-sentence, my head turned as if listening to a voice they couldn’t hear. My father, a man of few words and fewer superstitions, tried to reason with me. One evening, we were all in the living room, the television murmuring in the background. Gable was perched on the arm of the sofa, and Darla was kneeling by the window, watching the last light fade. My father said, ‘Son, you have to stop talking to thin air. It scares your mother.’ I felt a wrench of loyalty. I looked at Gable, who raised an eyebrow, and Darla, who shook her head slowly. But I loved my parents. I told them, ‘I can’t speak to them anymore.’ I never did again. The silence that followed was heavier than any noise, and a part of me froze inside.
The years passed. I grew up, went to school, made friends in a stilted, distracted way. But the world seemed to hum with a static I couldn’t tune out. Déjà vu struck me with dizzying frequency—every new place felt like a replay, every conversation a script I had already memorized. My dreams were not my own. I would wake gasping from visions of a burning house, a rusted well, a face pressed against a window that was not mine. And then, three years ago, during my junior year of college, I had a dream that changed everything. I was back in Dry Springs, standing before the old well. The cover was gone, and a cold draft rose from the depths. I leaned over, and I heard my own voice, but younger, echoing: ‘Gable, are you down there?’ And a voice answered, not from below, but from directly behind me, raspy and familiar: ‘No, but I’ve been waiting for you to come back.’
I woke in a cold sweat, my roommate shaking me. The details of the dream were so vivid I could still smell the moss and damp earth. Over the following weeks, a strange compulsion took hold. I began to sketch the well, the house, even the faces of Darla and Gable with frightening accuracy. My friends noticed my distraction, but I couldn’t explain that I felt like a puppet whose strings were being pulled again. Then, my grandmother, who had never spoken of the fire except to say it was ‘a child’s accident,’ fell ill. I visited her in the nursing home. Frail and tethered to oxygen, she gripped my hand with surprising strength. ‘John,’ she whispered, ‘I saw them before you did. I saw them in the old house, watching you. They’re not your friends. They’re threads of something that should have been cut.’ She died that night, and I was left with a key to the old property in Dry Springs, which she had kept in her jewelry box for years.
Now, at twenty, I stand at the end of a long dirt road, the summer heat pressing down like a hand. Our old house is a skeleton of its former self, the exterior weathered and the porch sagging. But the well is still there, behind a tangle of overgrown shrubs. I approach it, the key to the front door weighing heavy in my pocket, though I have no intention of opening it. The wooden cover I remember as rotten is gone, replaced by a neat stone rim, oddly new. I peer inside, expecting darkness, but instead I see a glint of metal at the bottom—a tin button, round and tarnished, like the ones I played with before the fire. A wave of nausea hits me. I hear a rustling behind me, like the sound of a dress dragging through leaves, and a low voice rumbles: ‘You came back. We’ve been waiting for three years. Longer, for me.’ I turn, but there’s nothing there. Only the house, its windows dark, and the sound of a child’s laughter, distant and mocking, from somewhere within. I realize with a cold certainty that this was never my choice. They let me go, but they never left. And the déja vu, the dreams, they were just the strings gently tugging me back to where the real story begins. I drop the key and run, but I know no matter how far I go, the well will always be behind me, and the buttons will always be scattered at the bottom, waiting for me to lean in and listen.