The summer I turned eleven, my mother finally told us the truth about the lake house. We had been coming to this place since we were born, a crooked wooden cabin that leaned into the birch trees like it was tired of standing. It belonged to our grandmother, who never spoke much, but always made sure there was a fifth plate at the table, even though there were only four of us.
My brothers, Caleb and Jonah, and I, we always thought it was just Grandma being senile. But that year, she was gone—had passed in the spring—and we went back one last time to sort through her things. My mother’s face was pale as she stood on the porch, the screen door creaking in the wind. She looked older, like she had been holding something heavy for thirty years and was about to set it down.
It was the first night, after a dinner of canned soup and crackers, that she gathered us in the musty living room. Jonah, my brother who always had that faraway look, sat by the window, watching the dark. ‘You know you were supposed to be quads,’ she said, her voice cracking. ‘Two sets of twins. But your sister… she died before she was born.’ I had heard bits of this before, but never all of it. She went on, ‘She was Jonah’s twin. And Jonah, you used to talk about her. You said your sister wanted to play.’
We all looked at Jonah. He was picking at a loose thread on the sofa, not meeting our eyes. ‘She’s still here,’ he said quietly. ‘She’s always been here.’
Caleb, my other brother, scoffed, but I felt a chill. In that moment, the house seemed to shrink, the walls closing in just a little. I had never seen her, not once. Why would she show only to Jonah? It was the question that had gnawed at me for years, the reason I started writing everything down in a green notebook I kept under my bed. I needed to understand why we were split—why two of us got to see, and two of us were blind.
That night, I couldn’t sleep. I lay in the narrow twin bed, listening to the wind rattle the glass. The clock on the nightstand ticked past 2:00 AM. Then I heard it—a soft thud, like small feet hitting the wooden floor. I sat up, my heart hammering. The room was dark, but the door was ajar, and in the hallway, there was a faint, milky light. I got up, my bare feet silent on the cold planks, and followed it.
The light led to the attic stairs, a ladder that folded down from the ceiling. I had never been up there, not once. Grandma always said it was off-limits, filled with ‘things that shouldn’t be touched.’ But the light was inviting, pulling me like a current.
I climbed, the wood groaning under my weight, and pushed open the trapdoor. The attic was enormous, filled with trunks and furniture draped in white sheets, like ghosts. The light was coming from the far corner, behind a stack of old suitcases. I moved them aside, and there, on a dusty dresser, was a photograph in a cracked frame. It was a baby picture, a girl with dark curls and a serious face. Her eyes were the same as Jonah’s—the same as mine, actually. Scrawled on the back in my grandmother’s spidery handwriting: ‘Daisy, sleeping before the light.’
I felt a hand on my shoulder and spun around. Jonah was standing there, his face pale in the glow. ‘She’s not sleeping,’ he said. ‘She’s waiting.’
‘Waiting for what?’ I whispered.
‘For one of us to take her place,’ he said. ‘Grandma knew. That’s why she set the fifth plate. She was trying to appease her.’
I stared at him, my mind racing. ‘What are you talking about?’
‘Daisy should have lived, and one of us should have died. But there was a mistake. We were supposed to be four, but we’re three, and she’s stuck here, unfinished. She can’t move on until she’s been allowed to live. And Grandpa—’ his voice broke, ‘—he used to play with her too. But he went into the woods and never came back. Grandma said he ‘went to be with Daisy.”
Suddenly, I understood the old woman’s silence, the way she always looked at the woods with a mix of fear and longing. The lake house wasn’t a vacation spot; it was a boundary. And Daisy was the one who kept it thin.
As if summoned, a cold breeze swept through the attic, extinguishing the light. In the darkness, I heard a child’s giggle, then a whisper, so close to my ear it tickled. ‘I want to play, Annie.’ But my name wasn’t Annie. It was Eleanor. And in that moment, I realized Daisy didn’t know my name. She didn’t know any of our names. She had been a baby when she died, and she had been frozen in that state, wanting a playmate, but not understanding that we were her siblings.
I felt a cold hand creep into mine, small and clammy. I looked down, but there was nothing there. I yanked my hand away and stumbled back. ‘No!’ I shouted, more to myself than to her.
Jonah grabbed me, pulling me toward the ladder. ‘We have to leave. She’s angry now.’
We scrambled down, falling onto the floor of the hallway. The attic door slammed shut above us, and we heard a furious, frustrated cry—a baby’s cry, but thin and wrong, like it was fading. Then silence.
Caleb was waiting in the hallway, his face ashen. ‘I heard it too,’ he said. ‘I saw her, for a second. She looked like me.’
That was when we understood. We had always thought we were alone in our blindness, but Caleb had seen her that night. And perhaps, the only reason we never saw her before was because we never went to the attic, never went to the place where she was strongest. The lake house—this boundary—was the only place she could reach us.
We packed our bags in the middle of the night, leaving the cabin behind without a second glance. But as I drove away with my mother and brothers, I couldn’t shake the feeling that Daisy was still there, watching us go. And I knew we had to come back, because we were the only ones who could set her free.
The question was, how? And what would it cost? I had the green notebook, filled with questions and observations. I would figure it out. I had to. Because that night, in the attic, I saw something else—a stack of papers, tucked behind the photograph. They were old medical records, and on top, in my mother’s handwriting, was a note: ‘Daisy was not stillborn. She was taken.’ Taken by whom? And why? The answer, I was sure, lay hidden in the lake house, waiting for us to return.
The car’s headlights cut through the dark, the cabin shrinking in the rearview mirror until it was a speck. But I could still feel Daisy, like a splinter under my skin. And in my green notebook, I wrote a new entry: ‘The Fourth Place Setting—where does she sit when we’re not here?’