I’ve heard a dozen tales about the old Motley farm, but none of them prepared me for what I saw with my own eyes. My girlfriend, Lena, her mother, and her mother’s boyfriend, Marcus, insisted we visit the place one last time before the property was sold off. It sat at the end of a winding, overgrown dirt road that snaked through miles of abandoned apple orchards. The trees were gnarled and diseased, their branches reaching out like grasping hands. The house itself was a sagging Victorian relic, its windows like hollow eye sockets.
We arrived just before dusk, the sky bleeding into shades of bruised purple and orange. Lena had grown up here, but she never spoke of it fondly. Her mother, Carol, was tense, chain-smoking cigarettes on the porch while Marcus fiddled with the lock on the front door. I brought my usual gear: a flashlight, a video camera, and a digital camera. I expected a few creaks, maybe some cold spots. I didn’t expect to feel watched from the moment we stepped inside.
The air was thick with dust and the smell of rotten apples. We explored the ground floor, our footsteps echoing on the warped hardwood. The walls were covered in faded floral wallpaper, peeling in long strips like dead skin. I snapped photos of everything, hoping to capture something anomalous. That’s when I noticed a door in the kitchen that led down to a cellar. It was padlocked, but Marcus produced a pair of bolt cutters from his truck.
As the lock snapped, a gust of cold air rushed up from the darkness, carrying a faint, sweet scent that made my stomach turn. We descended a rickety wooden staircase, our flashlights cutting through the oppressive black. The cellar was filled with old canning jars, their contents long since turned to unrecognizable sludge. But at the far end, there was a workbench with a single, worn ledger book lying open on its surface. The pages were covered in spidery handwriting, dates and notations that seemed to record something like harvests. But the last entry, dated October 31st, read: ‘They come when the apples turn. They sing to the roots.’
I took a picture of the ledger, and that’s when my camera’s flash flickered and died. My phone’s battery drained instantly, as if something had sucked the life from it. Lena grabbed my arm, her nails digging in. ‘We need to leave,’ she whispered. But Marcus laughed and said, ‘It’s just an old house, the power’s probably out.’
We climbed back up, leaving the cellar door open behind us. As we walked through the kitchen, I heard a sound from outside—a high, thin, wailing, like a woman singing a lullaby in a language I didn’t recognize. It came from the orchard. We all froze. Carol’s face went pale as milk. ‘That’s the song,’ she said, her voice trembling. ‘The one my grandmother used to hum. She said it was from the apple pickers who died in the field.’
I ran to the window and looked out. The trees seemed to shimmer under the pale moon, and for a split second, I saw silhouettes standing among them—tall, skeletal figures with elongated arms, swaying in unison. I raised my camera, but it wouldn’t turn on. I fumbled for my phone, but it was still dead. Lena screamed, pointing at the orchard. A figure was moving toward the house, its gait unnatural, limbs jerking as if puppeteered. I grabbed the camera and tried to shake it to life, but it just flickered and showed a photo I hadn’t taken: a close-up of a face pressed against a window, its eyes black pits, its mouth stretched impossibly wide.
That’s when the lights in the house began to flicker, and the singing grew louder, seeming to come from inside the walls. We ran for the front door, but it wouldn’t budge. The doorknob was ice cold, and the wood felt like it was vibrating. Marcus started to pound on the door, cursing. I turned to look at the kitchen, and the cellar door was open, but I could have sworn we left it closed. A pale, emaciated hand reached up from the darkness below, gripping the edge of the floor.
I didn’t think. I grabbed Lena’s hand and pulled her toward the back hallway, which led to a gnarled porch that faced the orchard. Without a second thought, we jumped off the railing and ran, our feet sinking into the frost-covered grass. The singing followed us, now a chorus, and behind us, I heard the sound of splintering wood. I didn’t look back. We tore through the orchard, the branches whipping our faces, and somehow made it to the truck. Marcus and Carol were already there, engines revving. We sped away, the road a blur of gravel and shadows.
When we finally stopped at a gas station miles away, I noticed I still had my digital camera. I turned it on, and it worked fine. I scrolled through the photos, and the last one was the one I had taken in the cellar—the ledger. But now, the handwriting had changed. It read, ‘They are in the truck. We are all here.’
I looked up from the camera, and in the reflection of the gas station window, I saw three figures standing behind us—their faces pressed against the lens of my memory, their mouths open in silent song. I haven’t been able to look at that photo since. It makes my eyes water, every time. And I know, deep down, they followed us home.