The first sign that something had changed was when the framed photograph of my father—him holding me as a baby, his face frozen in that gentle, unguarded smile—turned itself face-down on the mantel. I’d set it upright that morning, before heading to the mill. When I came home, it was reversed, the glass pressed to the wood, as if someone had carefully turned it over with two fingers. My girlfriend Elena shrugged it off, said it was the draft from the window. I didn’t mention that the window was shut and locked.
That was two weeks ago. Before the board, before the voices, before the thing in the shower. It started with my daughter, Lily, and her friend Tessa, who thought it would be a laugh to use the old Ouija board Elena had inherited from her grandmother. Elena had warned me it was “lively,” but she’d never used it herself, and I figured it was harmless—just a piece of painted cardboard and a plastic planchette, a prop for teenage giggles. They set it up in the living room one Saturday afternoon, candles lit, the lights dimmed. I heard their laughter, the fake séance voices, the occasional shriek of delight. I didn’t pay much attention.
Then, after they’d had their fun, I sat down with them. I don’t know why. Maybe it was the whiskey I’d had with dinner, or the ache of missing my father, who died when I was three, and my cousin Sam, who’d been my best friend and who’d died last year in a car accident. The board had been quiet for them, but when I placed my fingers on the planchette, it moved. Slow at first, as if testing me. It spelled out words: “I’M HERE.” I asked, “Dad?” The planchette slid to “YES.” A cold sweat broke out on my neck. I asked for proof, something only my father would know. The planchette spelled: “YOU USED TO HIDE IN THE CLOSET.” That was true, though I’d told no one. Lily and Tessa were watching, eyes wide. I pulled my hand away. “That’s it,” I said, and I carried the board outside, leaving it on the back porch in the rain. I thought that would be the end of it.
It wasn’t. That night, Elena called to me from the bathroom, her voice shaky. She said something had “grunted” at her from behind the shower curtain—two low, guttural sounds, like “ugh ugh.” I checked the bathroom, found nothing. I laughed it off, told her it was the pipes. But the next day, while I was at work, she messaged me: “Something is in the house. I can feel it.” She said she’d heard footsteps upstairs, and when she went to check, she found the bedroom door closed—a door I always kept open. She heard a whisper, too low to make out words, but it sounded like a man’s voice, and it wasn’t mine.
By the third day, I started to notice the salt. I’d always kept a small salt cellar by the door, for good luck, something my grandmother insisted on. Now, there were lines of salt across doorframes and windowsills, as if someone had spread them while I was at work. I asked Elena if she’d done it. She said no, but she had a strange look in her eyes. That night, I set up a camera in the hallway, pointed at the door to Lily’s room. In the morning, the footage showed nothing—just the empty hallway, the door opening and closing on its own. The salt lines were undisturbed, but there was a faint, damp footprint on the floor, too small to be mine or Elena’s.
Lily started having nightmares. She’d wake up screaming, saying there was a “man at the window” with “no face.” She described him as tall, wearing a long coat, and when he spoke, it was like gravel sliding down a drain. She said he told her “your daddy shouldn’t have played.” I tried to comfort her, but I could feel the coldness in the room, the air thick as if something were breathing beside us.
Elena’s behavior changed too. She started talking to herself, or to something else, in low murmurs. When I asked what she was doing, she’d say, “Just remembering,” but her eyes would dart to the corners of the room. One night, I heard her get up at 3 a.m. She walked to the kitchen, and I followed. She was standing at the counter, pouring salt into her palm. She brought it to her lips. I grabbed her wrist. “What are you doing?” She looked at me as if she’d just woken up. “It wants me to taste,” she said, and then she started crying.
I decided to get rid of the board. It was still on the porch, soaked through, the cardboard warped. I burned it in the backyard, the flames turning an odd greenish blue. As the smoke rose, I heard a voice behind me—a deep, rasping voice that came from the trees at the edge of the yard: “You can’t burn me.” I turned, but there was nothing. That night, I woke to the sound of scratching, like nails on plaster, coming from inside the walls. The scratching stopped when I turned on the light. In the morning, I found a message scratched into the doorframe of my bedroom: “I LIKED HER BETTER.”
I called a priest, but he took one look at the house and crossed himself, muttering about “a door that should stay closed.” He refused to go inside. I tried sage, crucifixes, holy water. Nothing worked. The activity intensified. Dishes flew off counters. Doors slammed. Elena began to speak in a voice that wasn’t hers—a man’s voice, low and venomous, calling me “boy” and telling me I “owed” him. I’d had enough. That evening, I packed a bag for Lily and Elena, intending to take them to her mother’s house. But when I came downstairs, they were gone. The house was silent. Too silent. The salt lines on the floor were broken, the salt scattered as if something had dragged through them.
I called Elena’s phone. It rang, and I heard it ringing from upstairs. I climbed the stairs, following the sound, which led me to the attic. The attic door was shut—I’d never opened it once. I pushed it open. Inside, the light was dim, and there was Elena, sitting in the center of the room, cross-legged, facing a mirror that I knew hadn’t been there before. She was rocking back and forth, humming a tune I recognized from my childhood—a lullaby my father used to sing. Lily sat in the corner, staring blankly at the wall. They didn’t react when I called their names. The mirror reflected nothing—just a black void, even though I could see the room behind it.
I stepped closer, and the mirror rippled, like water. I saw my father’s face—not as he was in the photograph, but older, gaunt, his eyes weeping black oil. He opened his mouth, and from it came the same gravel voice: “You shouldn’t have invited me.” I realized then that this wasn’t my father. It was something that had worn his face for me, and now it wore my girlfriend’s and my daughter’s faces. It was feeding on them, on their fear, on the warmth of our home. And it was feeding on me, too, because I had been the one to open the door.
I grabbed Lily and Elena, tried to drag them out, but they were like lead, heavy and unresponsive. The mirror began to crack, and from the cracks spilled a thick, black ooze that spread across the floor, eating through the wood. I heard a sound behind me—the “ugh ugh” Elena had described, but now it was a chorus, a dozen voices grunting in unison. I looked back, and the attic was full of them—tall, faceless figures, their heads cocked, watching me.
I don’t remember how I got out. I woke in the backyard, covered in mud, the house dark and silent. The front door was open, and I saw Lily and Elena standing on the porch, smiling at me. “Daddy,” Lily said, “we were waiting for you.” But their eyes were wrong—flat, like glass. Elena held out her hand, and in it was a small, rusted key. “He wants you to come back,” she said, in that gravel voice. “He says you owe him a life.” I backed away, but my feet wouldn’t move. The house loomed behind them, its windows like empty sockets. And I knew that no matter how far I ran, I would always be walking back toward that door.