It was the last long weekend of October in 1998, and I’d driven four hours from Gulfport to meet my old shipmates, Danny and Marcus, in a dusty town outside Baton Rouge called Meridian Flats. Danny had just gotten engaged to a woman named Cora, and he wanted me to meet her before the wedding. We’d served together on the USS Callahan, a frigate that had seen better days, and we’d earned our nickname, the ‘Hull Rats,’ from crawling through every bilge and pipe. Danny had that nervous energy he always got before a big reveal, and I figured it was just wedding jitters. Marcus, who’d flown in from Norfolk, was already at the bar when I arrived, nursing a beer and grinning at the jukebox. ‘You’re late, Ray,’ he said, sliding me a glass. ‘Danny’s got something to show us. Something weird.’
We met Danny and Cora at a rundown seafood shack on the edge of town, where the air smelled of catfish and diesel. Cora was a slim woman with quick eyes and a tattoo of a moth on her wrist. She laughed a lot, but it had a hollow ring. After the plates were cleared, Danny leaned in and lowered his voice. ‘Cora and her cousin found an old iron box in her grandmother’s attic. It had a wooden board inside, painted with letters and numbers. They thought it was a game. They started messing with it a few nights ago.’ He looked at Cora, who was staring at her drink. ‘I don’t like it. Something followed them home.’ Marcus snorted, but I saw Cora shiver. ‘What do you mean, followed?’ I asked. Cora pulled up her sleeve. On her forearm, a fresh scratch, three lines, red and raised, as if done by a claw. ‘It wrote my name in the dust on the mirror,’ she said. ‘And it’s been getting colder at night.’
The plan was to go to Cora’s grandmother’s house, a fading Victorian with peeling paint and a sagging porch, to return the board and ‘set things right,’ as Danny put it. We drove out that night, the headlights cutting through thick fog that rolled off the bayou. Inside, the air was thick with mothballs and old wood. The board lay on a dusty table in the parlor, surrounded by dried flowers. It was carved from dark wood, with a planchette that seemed too sharp, its edges like a blade. Cora’s cousin, a girl named June, was there, pale and trembling. She said they’d asked it a question: ‘Who are you?’ The planchette had spelled ‘CHALICE.’ No one had ever heard of that. Since then, the smell of rotting fruit had been following them. As we stood there, a floorboard creaked overhead. Marcus laughed nervously. ‘It’s just the house settling,’ he said. But then the planchette slid across the board on its own, stopping at ‘YOURS.’
We tried to burn the board in the backyard fire pit, but the wood wouldn’t catch, and the flames turned blue. The smoke formed a shape, like a tall figure with a long neck. Danny grabbed the board and said he’d drive it to a priest in Baton Rouge. But as he lifted it, the planchette flew off and struck him in the chest, sinking into his shirt. He staggered, and for a moment his eyes went white. Then he shook his head, and we all pretended not to see it. Cora started crying. Marcus was now pale, his joking gone. I felt a cold draft, and the moth on Cora’s wrist seemed to move, its wings twitching. June whispered, ‘It’s not done with us. It wants the one who let it in.'”
The night got worse. We decided to stay at the house, thinking it safer than driving. Cora and June went upstairs, and Danny, Marcus, and I took the downstairs bedrooms. I couldn’t sleep. I heard a scratching inside the walls, like nails. Then a voice, thin and far away, called my name: ‘Ray…’ It wasn’t Danny or Marcus. I grabbed my flashlight and went to the parlor. The board was back on the table, the planchette spinning. I shouted for the others. Danny came down, his face gray. He said Cora had locked herself in the bathroom, and June was gone. We found June in the attic, standing in the corner, her back to us. When she turned, her eyes were black, and her mouth was stretched in a grin too wide. She pointed at Danny and said, ‘He knows the way to the water.’ Danny’s face drained. ‘The water,’ he repeated, and started walking to the back door. We followed him outside, toward the bayou. The fog parted, and we saw a wooden dock. At the end, a figure stood, tall and thin, wearing a long coat. It didn’t move. Danny kept walking, as if hypnotized. Marcus and I grabbed him, but he struggled, stronger than he should be. The figure lifted a hand and beckoned. Then it spoke, in a voice like dry leaves: ‘You broke the circle. Now you must complete it.’
The wind picked up, and I saw that the figure’s feet didn’t touch the boards. Its coat billowed, but there was nothing inside it but darkness. I remembered the old stories, about spirits that feed on attention, that get a foothold when you invite them in. We had to break its hold on Danny. I pulled out my pocket knife and cut my hand, letting blood drip into the water. ‘We give you back your name, Chalice. We release you from our blood.’ The figure tilted its head. The water began to churn, and a vortex opened beneath the dock. The figure let out a shriek that sounded like a thousand crickets, and then it collapsed into itself, like a torn photograph. The fog lifted, and the moon came out. Danny collapsed, and Cora came running out of the house, crying. She said the board had turned to dust. We drove back to town in silence, the smell of rotting fruit finally gone. But on the way, I saw the moth tattoo on Cora’s wrist move again, and I knew it wasn’t over. We had sent it back, but it had tasted the world. It would find another way in. And next time, we might not be so lucky.