In December 2007, the small town of Millbrook was blanketed by an unseasonably early snowstorm. My niece, Jess, who was thirteen at the time, had come to stay with me for the holidays. As we sat by the fire on Christmas Eve eve, she noticed a stack of unopened Christmas cards on the table.
‘Aunt Carol, you haven’t sent your cards yet? The mail will be too slow!’
I chuckled, trying to sound nonchalant. ‘Only if the mailman catches me!’ I said, winking.
The truth was, I had been putting it off because I hated the cold, but Jess was insistent, and her enthusiasm was infectious. So, we bundled up and set out into the icy night, our boots crunching on the frozen snow.
The first few houses were easy. We slipped the cards into mail slots, tiptoeing and giggling like schoolgirls. The snow muffled our steps, and the streetlights cast long, warped shadows.
At the third house, I noticed the living room light was on. Through the window, I saw Mr. Hargrove, a kindly old man who lived alone, asleep in his armchair, his TV flickering silently. Jess pressed her face to the glass, stifling a laugh. I motioned for her to be quiet as I carefully lifted the brass flap of his mail slot.
Just as I released the card, Mr. Hargrove shifted in his sleep. We froze, barely breathing. I signaled to Jess that we should leave, but she was transfixed, watching him. So we took a step back, then another, our eyes locked on the window.
That’s when I noticed something odd. On the snowy path in front of Mr. Hargrove’s house, there were no footprints. We had made fresh tracks, but as I looked back, they were gone, filled in by an unseen hand. The snow around us was pristine.
I grabbed Jess’s arm, my heart starting to race. ‘Let’s go,’ I whispered, but my voice cracked.
As we turned to leave, I saw a figure at the end of the street. It was too far to make out clearly, but it seemed to be wearing a long coat and a wide-brimmed hat, like something from an old photograph. It stood perfectly still, watching us.
Jess saw it too. ‘Who’s that?’ she asked, her voice trembling.
‘I don’t know,’ I said. ‘Let’s just get home.’
We quickened our pace, but the figure didn’t move. When we finally reached our gate, I glanced back, and it was gone.
That night, I couldn’t sleep. The image of that figure haunted me. I told myself it was just a neighbor out for a walk, but something felt deeply wrong.
The next day, I decided to return to Mr. Hargrove’s house to apologize for the late card. As I approached, I saw that the snow on his path was untouched again, yet there was a fresh set of footprints leading from his door to the road, and then they stopped, as if he had been lifted into the sky.
Panicked, I rang his doorbell. No answer. I peered through the window and saw his chair empty, the TV still on. I called the police, and they found no signs of a struggle, but also no sign of Mr. Hargrove. He had simply vanished.
During the investigation, the police questioned me about the footprints. I showed them the snowy path, but by then, other prints had appeared, ours included. They dismissed it as a missing person case, but I knew better.
Later that evening, I found the Christmas card I had left for Mr. Hargrove lying on my doorstep, soaked in moisture, the envelope torn and the message inside missing. On the back, written in shaky handwriting, was a single sentence: ‘He came for me.’
I never mailed another Christmas card. And every year, on the night before Christmas, I see that figure standing at the end of the street, waiting, and I realize that some walks we take are not our own.