I was nine when the ceiling of our new loft began to feel like a second sky, one that watched. My sister Celia and I had always shared a room, huddled in twin beds pushed together like two ships lashed in a storm. But that autumn, Mom decided we were ‘too old’ for that, and she moved my bed to the far end of the loft, under the slanted eaves, where a single dormer window looked out onto the pines. Celia took the corner near the stairs, closer to the wood stove and the ladder to the upper bunk she claimed.
The loft was a vast, open space, but that night it felt like a cavern. I lay on my back, counting the knots in the wooden beams above, when I saw him. Not a man, not quite a shadow—a tall figure, nearly seven feet, standing in the corner where the wall met the beam. He wore a long, gray coat, like an old railroad conductor, and a wide-brimmed hat that obscured his face. But I knew he was smiling. Not a friendly smile, like Mr. Hirota, our shop teacher, who always praised my clumsy birdhouses. It was a patient smile, the kind you give a dog who’s about to bark at a stranger you already know.
I didn’t scream. I didn’t wake Celia. I just stared, and the figure stared back. And then I felt a warmth, not from the stove, but from deep in my chest—a calm that made my heart slow to a steady drum.
That week, I started to hear things. Not sounds, but in-between sounds. The creak of the loft floor when no one was there. The whisper of dry leaves against the dormer glass. And underneath them, a low hum, like a distant train on a track that didn’t exist. I told Celia about the figure, expecting her to laugh or call me brave. But she just frowned and said, ‘I know. He’s been watching me too.’
It was true. He came to both of us, always in the corner, always with that unseen smile. We started calling him the Conductor, because of the coat and the way he seemed to be waiting for something—for us to move, perhaps. But he never moved. He just stood, and the longer he stood, the more I felt like I was being taken apart, piece by piece, like a clock being disassembled by invisible hands.
Then one night, Celia shook me awake. Her eyes were wide, her voice a dry rasp. ‘He’s not in the corner. He’s at the foot of the bed.’ I looked. He was there, taller than ever, his hat brushing the beam. And for the first time, I saw something beneath the brim: a flash of white, like teeth. The smile was real.
He began to speak. Not with words, but with images. I saw a train—not a locomotive, but a thing of wood and iron, with windows that were mirrors. I saw us on the train, Celia and I, sitting side by side, but our reflections were gone. The hum grew louder, and I felt my body go light, as if I were being lifted from the mattress. I grabbed for Celia’s hand, but she was already rising, her face peaceful, like she was dreaming.
I knew then that we were being called. That the Conductor had been there all along, in all the corners of our lives, waiting for that exact moment. And I knew that if I let go, I would never see the loft again. But I also knew that if I held on, I would have to watch Celia go without me.
So I held on. I dug my nails into the sheets, my feet into the floor, and I screamed. Not in terror, but in defiance. The loft shook. The Conductor’s smile widened, and then he was gone, leaving only the hum, which faded like a train disappearing into a tunnel.
Celia fell back onto her bed, gasping. We never spoke of it again. But now, years later, I still check the corners of every room I enter. And sometimes, just sometimes, I see the faint outline of a hat brim in the dark, and I know he’s still smiling. Because he knows what I’ve learned: that there are two kinds of people—those who take the train, and those who watch the tracks. And I chose to watch. But I’m not sure which choice is more horrible.