It began in late October, when the wind off the reservoir turned brittle and the first frost painted the reeds silver. I was living alone in a converted water tower on the edge of Morrow County, a job that required me to catalog the rise and fall of the lake level for the county surveyor’s office. The tower was a relic of a forgotten era, a cylinder of rusted iron and peeling white paint, with a spiral staircase climbing to a single round room. That room was my home: a cot, a table, a gas stove, and a window that faced the water. The nearest neighbor was a hundred yards away, but they were the kind who kept to themselves and their hounds.
One night, I remember it was close to midnight, I had been reading by the weak glow of a kerosene lamp, the only light that didn’t cast long, dancing shadows. I set the book aside and closed my eyes, the hum of the wind outside my only lullaby. And then, abruptly, the hum stopped. No wind, no creaking of the tower’s bones, no distant bark of a dog, not even the occasional slosh of water against the pilings. It was as if the world had been muted, a thick blanket of silence smothering every sound. I opened my eyes, and in the corner by the door, a figure stood. He was the color of a bruise, a deep, unnatural blue, as though he had been dipped in indigo ink. I blinked, and he resolved into a man. His face was a wreck: a gash across his forehead had leaked down his cheek, his hair was matted and tangled, and his eyes were wide, unblinking, fixed on me with an intensity that made my skin crawl. He didn’t move. He just stared, as if he had been waiting for me to notice him.
Then, to my left, another blue figure moved. This one was small, a little girl, perhaps seven or eight, crouched by my footlocker, which I used as a closet. She was dressed in a thin cotton dress that hung to her knees, her hair long and dark, over her face. She wasn’t looking at me. She was playing with something on the floor, her hands moving in a pattern that I couldn’t quite follow, as if she were arranging invisible objects. She made no sound, no crinkle of paper, no click of a toy. Just the silent motion of her fingers.
My first thought was that I had fallen asleep and was dreaming, or worse, that the isolation had finally cracked me. I pulled the wool blanket over my head, squeezed my eyes shut, and willed myself to sleep. I chanted in my mind, ‘It’s not real, it’s not real,’ until exhaustion took me. When I woke, the sun was up, the wind was howling, and the tower was empty. I laughed it off as a nightmare, a vivid one, but just a nightmare.
A week passed. I had almost forgotten the incident, throwing myself into my work, measuring water levels, filing reports, and talking to the occasional fisherman who docked at the old pier. But then, on a night when the moon was hidden behind clouds, the silence descended again. This time, I was more alert. I had been lying in bed, reading, and when the noise cut off, I felt a prickle at the back of my neck. I kept my eyes glued to the page, but I knew something was there. Slowly, I looked up. The man was in the same corner, but now his arms were crossed over his chest, and he was tilting his head at an unnatural angle, as if his neck were broken. His stare was more intense, more demanding, as though he were angry that I hadn’t acknowledged him. The little girl was by the footlocker again, but this time she was standing, facing me, her hair still obscuring her face. She was holding a small, toy-like object in her hands, turning it over and over. I saw that it was a small, rusted key, like the kind you’d use for a clock or a music box.
I tried to scream, but my throat was dry, and only a rasp came out. I closed my eyes and whispered, ‘Go away. You’re not real.’ And then, as if my words had been a command, the silence broke. The wind picked up, the tower groaned, and I felt a wave of sound rush back in. When I opened my eyes, they were gone. But I felt a coldness in the room that lingered, and I noticed that the footlocker, which I had kept closed, was now slightly open, a sliver of darkness showing inside.
From that night on, they appeared more frequently. Not every night, but often enough that I stopped sleeping without a lamp on. I had tried to make sense of it, researching the history of the tower. It had been built in the 1920s to supply water to a nearby factory that had long since closed. There were stories of a caretaker who had gone mad and killed his daughter before turning the gun on himself, but they were just stories, the kind locals told to scare children. I didn’t believe them, but I began to wonder.
The man never spoke. He only stared, and as the weeks passed, his posture changed. Sometimes he would point at me, his finger trembling, his face contorted in a silent rage. Other times, he would shake his head slowly, as if in disappointment. The little girl was different. She seemed lost, her movements listless. Once, she looked up at me, and I could see her eyes: hollow, dark pits. She held out her hand, palm up, as if asking for something. I had no idea what.
Then came the night I made a mistake. I was exhausted, having slept poorly for days, and I had been reading about the old factory in a local history book. It mentioned that the caretaker had been a man named Jedediah, and that his daughter, Cora, had been found with a small music box beside her, the key still in her hand. The music box was never recovered. As soon as I read that, I felt a chill. I looked up from the book, and the man was there, inches from my face. His breath was cold, and I could see the glint of something in his hand: a small, rusted key, identical to the one the girl had been holding. He held it out to me, his eyes pleading, and then he pointed to the little girl, who was now in the center of the room, looking at me, her mouth open in a silent sob. The key was warm in my hand when he dropped it, and it clattered to the floor. And then they vanished, and the silence was replaced by a high-pitched whine that grew louder and louder until I covered my ears and screamed.
I fled the tower that night, leaving everything behind. I drove to the nearest town, checked into a motel, and tried to forget. But the key was still in my pocket. I couldn’t bring myself to throw it away. I had it appraised, and the antique dealer said it was a standard music box key, but there was a date scratched on the handle: ‘Oct 31, 1928.’ That was the same day the caretaker’s murder-suicide had occurred, according to the local records I later found. The next night, in the motel room, I saw them again. The man was standing at the foot of my bed, his arms crossed, looking at me with a mixture of rage and sorrow. The girl was sitting in the corner, humming a tune I didn’t recognize. The key in my pocket grew warm, and I understood, at last, what they wanted.
I returned to the tower the following morning. I had a plan. I found the place where I had dropped the key, and I searched the floorboards until I found a loose one. Beneath it, there was a small, tin music box, tarnished and dented, with a tiny crank on the side. I inserted the key, turned it, and the mechanism clicked and whirred. And then, a faint melody began to play, a lullaby that I had never heard but that felt achingly familiar. As the music filled the room, the two figures materialized before me. The man’s face softened, the tension in his shoulders relaxed. He looked at the girl, and she looked at him, and for the first time, she smiled. Then, they turned to me, and the man mouthed the words, ‘Thank you.’ And then, they faded, like smoke dissipating in the morning light. The music box played until the mechanism wound down, and then it stopped, and the silence returned. But this time, it was a peaceful silence, and the tower felt empty, truly empty, for the first time in years.
I left the music box on the floor of the tower, and I never returned. I moved to the city, got a job in an office, and tried to live a normal life. But sometimes, late at night, when the city noise falls just right, I feel a cold draft, and I hear the faintest strain of that lullaby. And I know that they are at peace, but they will never truly be gone. They are a part of me now, a static visitor in the back of my mind, waiting for the moment I let my guard down. And I wonder, sometimes, if I released them or if I trapped them in that key, and if someday, I will be the one holding the key, waiting for someone else to set me free.