My name is Eli. I was diagnosed with autism when I was eight, and while I’ve learned to handle the buzzing fluorescent lights and the grating sound of silverware on plates, I’ve never learned to handle the things that don’t follow the rules of the world. I’m terrified of the unexpected, of things that shift when they shouldn’t. So when our old toaster started clicking on at 3:00 AM, I knew it wasn’t just a faulty wire. It was something else.
We lived in a cramped, two-bedroom apartment above a laundromat in the rusting city of Port Ashford, where the fog rolled in every night like a tide of gray cotton. The building was old, with pipe organ walls that groaned and a furnace that hissed like a snake. My dad, Frank, worked nights at a chemical plant, so most evenings I had the place to myself, save for the mice and the dripping faucet.
The first incident happened about six months ago. I was in the bathroom, brushing my teeth, when I caught a flicker of movement in the mirror. A shadow, maybe? I spun around, my toothbrush still in my mouth, but the bathroom was empty. Just the yellowed tiles and the rusted drain. I told myself it was a trick of the light, that my brain was doing what it always did—finding patterns where there were none.
But then I saw them while walking back to my room: pale, ghostly legs, from the knee down, disappearing around the corner into the kitchen. They were the legs of a young man, I think, wearing checkered pajama pants that looked like they belonged to a hospital. My heart hammered. I stood frozen, listening for any sound. Nothing. I crept to the kitchen, the floorboards creaking under my socks, but there was no one there. Just the old toaster, its metal body reflecting the flickering streetlight from the window.
That’s when the toaster clicked. And clicked again. And again. It was unplugged—I always unplugged it after breakfast—but it still clicked, the lever moving up and down as if an invisible hand were pressing it. I watched, my breath shallow, as two slices of toast began to rise, slowly, charred and smoking. The smell of burnt bread filled the air. Then the clicking stopped. I felt a cold spot beside me, like someone was standing there, watching me. My skin prickled.
I ran to my room and locked the door, but I couldn’t shake the feeling that something was in the apartment with me. I texted my dad, but he didn’t reply. He was probably elbow-deep in chemicals, deaf to the world. I sat on my bed, knees hugged to my chest, trying to regulate my breathing the way my therapist taught me. But the air felt heavy, charged, like before a thunderstorm.
The next day, I told my dad about the toaster. He laughed, that low rumbling chuckle of his. ‘It’s just old,’ he said, and he flicked the switch on the toaster—still unplugged—and it clicked once, obediently. I didn’t find it funny. The toaster had never done that before.
This happened right before my grandmother passed away. She lived three states south, in a tiny yellow house with rosebushes that always collapsed under their own weight. Dad and I drove eight hours to see her in the hospital. She was hooked up to machines, her skin like parchment, and when she saw me, she gripped my hand with a surprising strength and whispered, ‘The old one is restless. He never liked being forgotten.’ I had no idea what she meant. She died that night at 2:47 AM.
The next month, things escalated. The grandfather clock in the hallway—which had been broken since before I was born—started chiming at odd hours. Not the correct time, never the correct time. At 3:33 AM, it would chime thirteen times, the last note hanging in the air like a held breath. I tried to muffle it with a pillow, but the sound seemed to come from inside my head.
Then the wooden floor in the living room would groan, as if someone was walking across it, though the floor was carpeted. I’d watch the fibers depress, a heavy presence moving from the window to the old rocking chair in the corner. The chair would rock, slowly, back and forth, even when the air was still. I couldn’t sit in that room anymore. I’d eat my frozen dinners in the kitchen, back to the wall, eyeing the toaster.
One night, I decided to confront it. ‘Who are you?’ I asked, my voice trembling. The kitchen light flickered. But nothing else happened. I felt a touch on my shoulder, light as a feather, and I jumped, yelping. I turned, but there was no one. I didn’t sleep that night. I lay in bed, staring at the ceiling fan, which occasionally clicked on by itself, spinning lazily, even though I had it off.
I called my dad, who was at the plant, and begged him to come home. But he said he couldn’t. ‘It’s just the house,’ he said. ‘It’s just the wind.’ But I knew better. This wasn’t the wind. This wasn’t a faulty toaster or a dying clock. This was something that had been here long before us, and it was waiting.
On my birthday, the toaster did something new. It popped out a piece of bread with the word ‘ELI’ burned into it. I stared at it, my heart racing. The letters were deep, dark, cooked into the crust. I didn’t eat bread. I hadn’t bought bread in weeks. I threw the toast in the trash, but the smell of burning lingered for days.
I began to research the history of the building. The laundromat below had been a funeral home in the fifties. I found old records online, black-and-white photos of a young man in a wheelchair, his face half-hidden in shadow. His name was Arthur, and he’d been a patient in an asylum that once stood nearby. He’d died in a fire in 1953, trapped in a basement room. The asylum was demolished in the sixties, but the funeral home remained. The image of his legs—thin, pale, like the ones I saw—haunted me.
I started leaving a piece of bread in the toaster every night, not to tempt it, but as an offering. I wasn’t sure why. It felt right. And every morning, the bread was gone, and there would be a tiny pile of ashes in the toaster tray, as if it had been burnt to a crisp. I never turned it on.
Then, one morning, I woke up at dawn, my room bathed in a sickly yellow light from the streetlamp. The fan was spinning, though I’d shut it off. My door was open. I froze, listening. From the kitchen, I heard the toaster’s lever click down, and a whirring sound, followed by a soft, rhythmic ‘tick-tick-tick’—like a clock counting down. I crept to the doorway.
There, in the dim light, sat a figure at the kitchen table. It was a young man, wearing checkered pajama pants, his back to me. He was hunched over, one hand on the toaster, the other tapping the table. I couldn’t see his face, but I knew it was Arthur. I wanted to run, but my legs wouldn’t move. He turned his head slowly, and I saw his profile. His skin was gray, like ash, and his eyes were dark hollows.
‘You found me,’ he said, but his lips didn’t move. The voice came from inside my head.
I shook my head. ‘I didn’t want to,’ I whispered.
He gestured to the toaster. ‘It’s the only thing that keeps me here. The connection. The heat. The memory.’
I didn’t understand. He stood up, and that’s when I saw his legs fully—they were transparent, like wavering heat, but the checkered pants were solid, as if painted on. He took a step toward me, and the air went cold. ‘You think you’re afraid of me,’ he said. ‘But I’m not here to hurt you. I’m here to warn you.’
‘Warn me?’ I managed.
‘Your grandmother knew. She was the last one who could see me. She tried to help, but she’s gone now. The toaster was her idea. A hub. A way to communicate. But now, something else is coming. Something older, darker. It’s been sleeping beneath this building, feeding on the grief. It woke when she died.’
I staggered back. ‘What is it?’
He shook his head, and his form began to blur. ‘Don’t let it find you. It wants to become real. It will steal your skin and wear it. I can keep it at bay for a while, but you have to leave this apartment. Tonight. Before the toaster fails.’
He flickered, and for a moment, I saw the toaster behind him, glowing red, the coils white-hot. Then everything snapped back. He was gone, and the kitchen was empty. The toaster was unplugged, its lever up.
I didn’t hesitate. I grabbed my phone and my keys, and I ran out the door, not even bothering to put on shoes. I called my dad, screaming into the speaker, and he said he was on his way. I stood on the stairwell, shivering in the fog, watching our apartment door. Through the window, I saw a pale glow growing in the kitchen, the toaster bursting into a silent flame.
I never went back. Even after the fire was extinguished, even after the insurance people and the firefighters and the neighbors all said it was an electrical fault, I knew the truth. The toaster was never faulty. It was a door.
Now, I live with my dad in a new development on the outskirts of Port Ashford, where the houses are all identical and the fog never quite reaches. But sometimes, at night, I’ll hear a faint ticking from the kitchen, and I’ll find a piece of bread in the toaster, even though I never bought any. And I’ll know that Arthur is watching, his ghost legs pacing, waiting for the next person to ask too many questions.
I don’t sleep well. I never will. But I’ve learned one thing: the things in the walls are not always what they seem. Sometimes, they’re warning you. And sometimes, they’re not.