The first time I saw the moth, I was eleven, standing at the kitchen window of our new rental in Dustford, a town that had more empty storefronts than people. The house itself was a squat, brick thing from the 1950s, with a yard that grew more gravel than grass. I remember pressing my nose to the glass, watching a pale, oversized moth beat against the screen, its wings the color of dried bone. It left a fine, gray powder on the mesh, and I remember thinking it looked like the frost on my grandmother’s grave.
We’d moved there after my father lost his job, and my mother took a position as the night nurse at the county hospice. The house was cheap, drafty, and smelled of damp carpet and old wires. My sister, Priya, was nine and hated everything about it, especially the way the floorboards creaked at odd hours, even when no one was walking. I told her it was just the house settling, but I didn’t believe it myself. Sometimes, when I woke up at 3 a.m. to use the bathroom, I’d see a figure standing at the end of the hallway—a tall, thin shape that was too still, too dark, and then it would be gone when I blinked.
A month after we settled in, I had the dream. It was not a normal dream; it was like the air itself had thickened, pressing down on my chest until I couldn’t breathe. I woke with a gasp, my heart rattling like a captured bird. The room was bathed in the sickly yellow glow of the streetlight outside, and I knew, with a certainty that felt like ice down my spine, that I was not alone. I didn’t want to look, but something made me turn my head toward the corner where Priya’s bed sat.
There she was. A woman, or what had once been a woman. Her hair was a wild, matted tangle, the color of old hay, and when I squinted, I could see the outline of her cheekbones pressing against skin that was too thin, like parchment stretched over a drum. She was standing perfectly still, her hands clasped in front of her, and she was staring directly at me. I couldn’t make out her eyes—they were just dark pits—but I felt the weight of her gaze like a physical thing, pressing into my forehead.
I reached for the lamp, fumbling with the switch, and when the light clicked on, she was still there. She didn’t vanish. Instead, she tilted her head, and the motion was so unnatural, so fluid, that I felt bile rise in my throat. Her mouth opened, but no sound came out. Instead, a fine, gray dust—like the moth powder from the screen—fell from her lips and drifted to the floor. Then, as if satisfied, she turned and walked toward the closet, dissolving into the darkness of the doorframe.
I didn’t sleep that night. I sat with my back to the wall, knees drawn to my chest, listening to Priya’s soft breathing and the knocking of the heating ducts. The next morning, I told my parents, but they dismissed it as a nightmare, blaming the cheap wine my mother had with dinner. Priya, though, looked at me with a new fear in her eyes. She whispered, ‘I saw her too,’ and then refused to say more.
Over the next weeks, the presence grew bolder. I would find piles of the gray dust in corners of my room, forming shapes that I just couldn’t read—like words in a language I didn’t know. One night, I woke to find Priya standing at the foot of my bed, her eyes open but vacant, her lips moving as if she were whispering a conversation with someone only she could hear. When I shook her awake, she screamed and said there was a lady in her closet who wanted to take her ‘somewhere pretty.’
The hospice where my mother worked had a small garden, a patch of dying roses and a bench. I went there every day after school, not because I liked it, but because the lady never seemed to follow me there. One afternoon, I overheard my mother talking with one of the nurses. The nurse said, ‘They found her in the basement, you know. The old woman who used to live in your house. She had no visitors, no family. She died alone, and they didn’t find her for two weeks. The landlord just sealed it up after the cleanup.’
I felt a cold sweat break out on my neck. I asked my mother what the woman’s name was, and she said, ‘I don’t know, sweetheart. The papers just called her a recluse. But they said she was obsessed with something—moths. Apparently her bedroom was filled with jars of them.’
That night, I knew what I had to do. I waited until my parents were asleep, and I crept down to the basement. The door was padlocked, but there was a small, rusted gap at the bottom. I slid my hand through and felt the lock. It gave way with a click, as if it had been waiting for me. The stairs creaked under my weight, and the air was thick with dust and the smell of something sweet and old, like rotting fruit.
At the bottom, in the weak beam of my flashlight, I saw it: a single, large glass jar on a workbench, covered in a thick layer of gray dust. Inside were hundreds of dead moths, their wings pressed against the glass, their brittle bodies frozen in a perpetual flutter. As I stared, one of them twitched. Then another. Then, with a sound like dry leaves skittering, they all began to move at once, beating against the glass, their wings shedding the gray powder that now filled the air.
I heard a voice behind me, soft and dry as a whisper. ‘You found my children.’ I turned, and she was there, closer than ever before, her hair now hanging in lank strands, her fingers long and white. She reached out, and I saw that her nails were caked with the same gray dust. ‘You’re just like me,’ she said. ‘You see what no one else can. You’ll feed them now.’
I stumbled backward, but the stairwell was gone. In its place was a wall of moths, their wings beating a rhythm that sounded like a heartbeat. I closed my eyes, and when I opened them, I was back in my bed, the lamp still on, the room empty. The next morning, I found a gray dust-coated jar on my nightstand. Inside, a single moth, and a slip of paper that read: ‘Feed me.’
My mother found me a few days later, sitting on the kitchen floor, surrounded by dozens of dead moths, my fingers gray with dust. I didn’t remember how they got there. I just remember the lady’s smile, and the way the moths’ wings felt like dry kisses on my skin. The doctor said it was a psychotic break, brought on by the move and the stress. But I know better. The lady didn’t want the jar; she wanted a new pair of eyes. And now, every time I see a moth flutter at the window, I wonder if she’s found them.