The night my cousin Marta brought up the old Trapp house, we were all sitting on the porch of my grandmother’s farmhouse, swatting at mosquitoes and listening to the cicadas screech in the Alabama heat. It was one of those sticky, breathless evenings when the air felt thick as syrup. My uncle Joel, who had a way of telling stories that made your skin crawl, leaned forward in his rocking chair and said, ‘You all remember the Trapp house, right? On County Road 9? The one with the burnt-out barn and the overgrown hedges? I had an encounter there last fall, and I still can’t shake it.’ I thought I knew all the stories about that place, but what he told us that night was something I’d never heard before.
According to Joel, he was driving back from a job late one night, and his truck started overheating. He limped it along until he saw the Trapp property and decided to pull into the long, rutted driveway to pop the hood and let the engine cool. The house was a sagging Victorian, its windows like black sockets, and the yard was a tangle of weeds and dead rose bushes. As he was pouring water into the radiator, he noticed a faint, flickering light coming from the attic window. It was a warm, orange glow, like a lantern, not the cold blue of a flashlight or the harsh white of a bulb. He felt a pull toward it, a curiosity that overrode his better judgment. He climbed the creaking porch steps, the wood groaning under his boots, and pushed the front door open. It wasn’t locked.
Inside, the air was heavy with the smell of dust and something sweet, like rotting fruit. The furniture was draped in white sheets, and his footsteps echoed in the emptiness. He made his way up the stairs, guided by that light spilling down from the attic. At the top, there was a small door with a latch. He lifted it, and the attic opened before him. It was mostly empty, save for a single red lantern sitting on a wooden crate in the center. The light pulsed gently, casting a crimson glow that made the shadows dance. Joel felt a sudden dread, but he couldn’t move. A voice, like honey and rust, whispered from the lantern: ‘You’ve come to see me.’ Joel tried to run, but his legs were rooted to the floor. The voice continued, ‘You’re the first in a long time. The last one, she was a woman with a blue dress. She called me by my name. She knew it. Now you will learn it.’
Joel said he finally managed to back away, stumble down the stairs, and out into the night. He drove home without looking back, and he never told anyone until now. As he finished, my grandmother, who had been sitting silently in the corner, went pale. She whispered, ‘That was my aunt Margaret. She went to that house years ago, to see the old woman who lived there. She said she was just going to wave from the gate, but something made her go in. She never came out. They found her in the attic, her face frozen in a scream. The lantern was glowing red beside her.’
We all sat in silence, the cicadas suddenly loud in the stillness. Then my cousin Mark, a skeptic, scoffed and said, ‘That’s just a folk tale, Aunt May. You’re scaring the kids for fun.’ But my grandmother shook her head. ‘No, Mark. That lantern is real. And it’s not finished. It calls people to it, especially those who are curious or lost. It makes them whisper its name, and once they do, they become one of the voices inside.’ She looked at me then, and I felt a chill. ‘You’ve been asking about that house, haven’t you? You’ve been thinking about going there.’ I had, actually, but I hadn’t told anyone. I just shrugged. My grandmother grabbed my hand, her grip surprisingly strong. ‘Don’t. Promise me, child.’ I nodded, but, as the night went on, I couldn’t shake the image of that red lantern.
A week later, I was driving home from a friend’s house when my car started sputtering, right near the old Trapp place. I had my grandmother’s warning in my head, but sure enough, my car died in front of the gate. I tried to start it, but it was dead. I got out, and I saw it: a faint, orange glow flickering in the attic window. I knew I should walk to the nearest house, call a tow truck, anything. But my feet moved on their own, crunching the gravel, stepping onto the porch. The front door was ajar. I pushed it open and stepped inside. The air was thick, and I could hear a faint humming, like a lullaby from my childhood. I walked up the stairs, not feeling my legs, and I opened the attic door.
There it was, the red lantern, pulsing on the crate. As I walked toward it, a whisper filled my ears, a chorus of voices, all saying the same name over and over: ‘Margaret, Margaret, Margaret.’ And then, a clearer voice, sweet and seductive, said, ‘Now you know my name. Join me.’ I felt my mouth open, ready to speak, but at the last second, I remembered my grandmother’s face, her desperate plea. I clenched my jaw and forced myself to turn around. I ran down the stairs, out the door, and didn’t stop until I reached the main road. My car was still dead, but I ran until I found a gas station and called my uncle. When he picked me up, he didn’t ask questions. He just looked at me and said, ‘You know now. But you can’t tell anyone. Once you’ve heard the name, it stays with you. It will haunt you, but if you ever say it aloud, it will come for you.’
I haven’t told anyone that night, not the name, not what happened. I’m writing this story in secret, and I’m changing the details to protect myself. But I need to get it out, because the memory is burning in my head. I can still hear that humming, and sometimes, at night, I see a faint orange glow in my window, just for a second. I know I did the right thing, but I also know the lantern remembers me. It’s patient. And one day, maybe when my guard is down, it will call my name, and I’ll have no choice but to answer. I’m afraid that day isn’t far away.