It was the spring of 2015, and I was two weeks away from my senior prom. My best friend, Cassie, and I had planned to celebrate at a fancy Italian place downtown, but we’d heard the wait could be brutal, so I decided to call ahead and make a reservation. I was seventeen, still too shy to order my own pizza without rehearsing, but I figured a phone call couldn’t be that hard.
I dialed the number for Luigi’s Trattoria, a cozy spot that had just opened near the old train station. The phone rang twice, then a woman answered, her voice warm and syrupy: ‘Thank you for calling Luigi’s Trattoria. How can I help you?’
I stammered, ‘Um, hi, I’d like to make a dinner reservation for two, please.’ There was a pause, then a click, and I found myself on hold. I expected some cheesy accordion music, the kind they play in every red-sauce joint. But instead, I heard what sounded like wind. Not the gentle breeze of a summer day, but a roaring gust, as if a storm was tearing through a hollow tunnel. And within that wind, I could swear I heard whispers—fragmented, garbled, almost like words struggling to surface.
I pressed the phone closer, my heart beginning to pound. The whispers grew clearer, and I made out a voice, thin and reedy, like an old man’s, saying, ‘Twelve… twelve… the last table…’ Then a young girl’s voice, giggling, ‘Don’t forget the special sauce.’ I shook my head, telling myself it was just a bad connection, some radio interference from the station nearby. But the wind kept howling, and the whispers swirled around me.
Then, without warning, the hold music clicked off. A man’s voice, deep and smooth, came on the line. ‘This is Tony. Thank you for calling Luigi’s. How many in your party?’ I cleared my throat and repeated, ‘Two, for dinner, please.’
‘Certainly,’ Tony said. ‘And may I have your name?’ I told him, and he said, ‘Ah, yes. We have a table ready for you and your friend. But you must be prompt. The kitchen closes at dusk, and the last reservation is at twilight. Do not be late.’ I thought it was odd, since it was April and dusk was past seven, but I just said, ‘Okay, we’ll be there at six-thirty.’ Tony chuckled, a low, wet sound, and said, ‘Perfect. We’ll have the special waiting.’ Then he hung up without a goodbye.
That night, I couldn’t shake the feeling of unease. I called Cassie and told her about the strange phone call. She laughed it off. ‘Probably some prank the cooks play. You’re such a worrier.’ But when I went to bed, I dreamed of a long, dimly lit corridor lined with tables, each covered in white cloths, and at the far end, a single chair facing a mirror. In the mirror, my reflection was older, gaunt, and it smiled at me with black teeth.
On prom night, I picked up Cassie in my dad’s old sedan. She looked beautiful in her emerald dress, her hair curled. I felt a pang of guilt for dragging her to this strange place, but she was excited. ‘I’ve heard the gnocchi is to die for,’ she said. We drove through the city, past the glowing signs of fast food joints, until we reached the old station. Luigi’s was nestled under a rusty overpass, its facade lit by a single flickering sign that spelled ‘Luigi’s Trattoria’ in cursive, but the ‘r’ in ‘Trattoria’ was burned out, so it read ‘Trattoia’.
We walked in. The place was empty. Not just empty of customers, but empty of everything—no menus on the tables, no drinks, no sound except a low hum. A man in a black suit appeared from a doorway. He was tall, with slicked-back hair and a smile that didn’t reach his eyes. ‘Welcome, welcome,’ he said, his voice exactly like Tony’s, deep and smooth. ‘Right this way.’ He led us past rows of tables, all set for one, each with a single candle in a glass bowl, the flames burning steady and silent. At the back, he stopped at a table for two, covered in a crisp white cloth. The chair on my side was normal, but Cassie’s side had a high-backed, throne-like chair with intricate carvings of vines and thorns.
‘Please, sit,’ Tony said, pulling out the throne for Cassie. She shot me a nervous glance but sat down. I took the regular chair, my knees almost hitting the table. Tony handed us menus, thick leather-bound books. I opened mine. The font was old-fashioned, but the items were bizarre. ‘Insalata di Cenere’ (Salad of Ashes), ‘Bistecca alla Memoria’ (Steak in Memory), ‘Gelato di Sospiri’ (Ice Cream of Sighs). I looked at Cassie’s menu; she was staring at hers, her face pale.
‘What is this?’ I whispered. She pointed to an item: ‘Spaghetti del Cuore Spezzato’ (Spaghetti of the Broken Heart). Underneath, in small letters, it said, ‘Served with a side of regret.’ Now I was certain something was wrong. I closed my menu and said, ‘I think we’d like to leave.’
Tony’s smile never faltered. ‘But you ordered the special,’ he said. ‘It’s already been prepared. The last table… it’s for you.’ He snapped his fingers, and the lights dimmed. From the kitchen, I heard the whistling again—the same wind, the same whispers. The door behind Tony swung open, and a woman emerged carrying a silver cloche. She set it in the center of the table. ‘The special,’ she said, her voice like a sigh. She lifted the cloche.
Underneath was a plate. On the plate was a single photograph, yellowed and curled. I picked it up. It was a picture of Cassie and me, but we looked older, maybe forty, standing in front of this very restaurant, except it was abandoned, boarded up. In the photo, our faces were gaunt, our eyes hollow, and behind us, in a second-floor window, a shadowy figure watched. I dropped the photo. Cassie grabbed it, staring in horror.
‘What is this?’ she demanded, her voice shaking. Tony leaned in, his breath cold on my ear. ‘You called for a reservation. You didn’t listen to the whispers. Some doors, once opened, can’t be closed.’ He gestured to the photograph. ‘This is where you’ll end up. Not tonight, but someday. You’ll come back here, and you’ll sit at this table, and you’ll eat the special of the day.’
I grabbed Cassie’s hand. ‘Run!’ We bolted for the door, but the corridor seemed endless, and each table we passed had a new photograph, each one showing a different version of our future—one where we were old and sick, one where we were buried in the same grave, one where we were connected by a red thread that turned into a noose. The exit grew closer, but the air grew colder, and the whispers grew louder, until they were screaming.
Finally, we burst through the front door, stumbling into the parking lot. The sign was no longer flickering; it was dark. The windows of the restaurant were boarded up, and the building looked abandoned, decades old. We ran to the car, and I fumbled for the keys. As we drove away, I looked in the rearview mirror. The restaurant was gone, replaced by an empty lot overgrown with weeds. Cassie was crying, clutching my arm. Neither of us spoke until we were miles away.
I never told anyone what happened, not even my parents. But sometimes, when the phone rings, and I hear that wind, I know it’s Tony again. And I know that one day, we’ll go back. We’ll sit at that table, and we’ll eat the special. The reservation, after all, was for two.