My girlfriend, Lena, lived in an old farmhouse that her family had owned for generations. It was a place that always felt wrong, as if the walls themselves were holding their breath. I’d been staying over for about a week, and while I loved Lena, I hated the nights. The house was pitch black after midnight, and I had an intense fear of the paranormal, a fear that was only fed by Lena’s stories. She had an imaginary friend as a kid named ‘Murmur’ who turned out to be a ghost that still whispered to her at odd hours. Her mother, too, had countless encounters with the other side, and the house was a repository of their spectral leftovers.
That particular night, I woke up around 3 AM with a gnawing hunger. I quietly slipped out of bed, careful not to disturb Lena, and padded barefoot down the hallway. The hall was a void, so thick I couldn’t see my own hand in front of my face. I used the wall as a guide, feeling the peeling wallpaper under my fingers. My heart thumped in my ears, and every creak of the old floorboards sent a jolt through me. I finally reached the kitchen and fumbled for the light switch, but it clicked uselessly. The bulb must have burned out. I cursed under my breath, feeling along the counter for a plate.
As my fingers closed around a ceramic dish, a shape on the wall caught the faint light coming from the moon outside. It was a tall, humanoid silhouette, about six feet high, with a sharply angled hat on its head. I froze. My mind screamed ‘shadow man,’ and I knew it was real. The shadow didn’t move, just stood there, as if waiting. I felt a cold dread wash over me, and my legs turned to jelly. I couldn’t bear to look at it any longer. I turned and ran back to the bedroom, my heart hammering, and dove under the covers, pressing myself against Lena’s sleeping form.
I lay there, trembling, trying to convince myself it was just my imagination, a trick of the light. But I knew better. I’ve read about these things, heard stories, but never experienced one. Lena stirred and mumbled, ‘What’s wrong?’ I whispered, ‘There’s something in the kitchen. A shadow.’ She sighed, as if it were an old nuisance, and said, ‘It’s just Murmur. He likes to wander at night. He won’t hurt you, just ignore him.’ She rolled over and went back to sleep. I, however, lay awake, my eyes fixed on the doorway.
Minutes passed, maybe an hour. I was on the edge of sleep when I heard a sound—a soft, shuffling noise coming from the hallway. It grew closer, and then a dark, human-shaped form filled the doorway. It was taller than any man, and the hat was unmistakable. It stood there for a moment, then took a step into the room. I wanted to scream, but my voice was gone. I could feel its gaze on me, a pressure like static. It moved slowly towards the other bed, the one Lena now used as a catch-all for laundry. It stood beside it, and then it sat down, as if it were going to sleep. The shape settled, and the room seemed to grow colder.
I shut my eyes, praying for it to leave. After a long while, I felt the presence retreat. I opened my eyes to see the doorway empty. The room had returned to its normal temperature. I didn’t sleep the rest of the night, and at dawn, I told Lena I couldn’t stay there anymore. She seemed sad but understanding. As I gathered my things, she said, ‘He only appears when someone is afraid. He feeds on that. If you come back, don’t be scared. He’ll leave you alone.’ I didn’t have a chance to respond. I just got in my car and drove away.
Weeks later, I still couldn’t shake the image of that shadow. I avoided Lena’s house, but she kept calling. One night, I woke up in my own apartment to see a familiar silhouette in the corner of my bedroom. The fedora was unmistakable. It stood there, watching me. I knew then that he had followed me home, and that he would never leave. I was his new company.