The Man at the Stove

6 min read

Story Premise 6 min read (1,022 words)

"It was the winter of my tenth year, and my parents had decided to host a grand Christmas Eve party. Our house, a creaky Victorian relic on the edge of a small town, was the only one on the block with a real fireplace, and the guests loved to gather around it. By the time […]"

It was the winter of my tenth year, and my parents had decided to host a grand Christmas Eve party. Our house, a creaky Victorian relic on the edge of a small town, was the only one on the block with a real fireplace, and the guests loved to gather around it. By the time the last carol had been sung and the last glass of wassail drained, my eyelids were heavy with the warmth of the house and the lingering scent of cloves and pine.

I was told to sleep in the study, on an old chaise lounge that had been dragged in from the porch because my room was being repainted. The chaise had a metal lever on the side that, when pulled, would lift a footrest and recline the back. I remember fumbling with it in the dark, the click of the mechanism echoing in the quiet room, before I finally settled into a position that felt like lying in a hammock.

The study faced the kitchen, separated by a wide, open doorway. The kitchen was the heart of our home, with a massive black stove that my grandmother had used for decades. It was the kind of stove that had a long metal handle that you could swing out to hold a kettle. My mother always said that stove had a personality, and I believed her, especially on nights when the wind would whistle through the cracks and the stove would emit a low groan, as if it were sighing in appreciation of the warmth.

I don’t know what time I woke. The house was silent, save for the ticking of the grandfather clock in the hallway. The fire had died to embers, painting the room in a dim orange glow. I lay there, staring at the ceiling, feeling the weight of sleep still pressing on my limbs, when I heard a footstep. It was a soft, deliberate step on the wooden floor, and it came from the kitchen.

I turned my head, and there he was: a man, tall and broad-shouldered, standing in the middle of the kitchen, facing the stove. He wore a long, dark coat that brushed the floor, and a top hat, the kind I’d seen in old photographs of wealthy ancestors. His back was to me, but I could see the shine of his leather shoes catching the faint light. He didn’t move, just stood there, as if waiting for the stove to speak.

My first instinct should have been fear. But instead, a strange calm washed over me. It was like the feeling you get when you’re in a half-remembered dream, and you know you’re dreaming, so nothing can hurt you. I watched him, not daring to make a sound, as he slowly raised his right hand and placed it flat on the stovetop. The stove was cold, but he left it there for a long moment, as if feeling for something. Then, he turned his head slightly, and I saw the profile of a clean-shaven jaw and a straight nose, but his face was obscured by the brim of his hat.

He then moved his hand to the handle of the stove, the one that my mother used to pull out the kettle. I watched him grip it and begin to turn it, back and forth, back and forth, as if he were stirring a pot. The handle clicked each time it rotated, and in the silence, it sounded like a door being knocked. I remember thinking, ‘He’s making tea.’ And that made perfect sense to me. It was the middle of the night, and he wanted tea.

The man continued his motions, not fast, not slow, but with a methodical rhythm. The handle squeaked, and I felt my eyelids grow heavy again. I was not afraid. I was not alarmed. I simply felt a deep exhaustion take over, and I closed my eyes.

When I woke, the morning light was streaming through the curtains, and the stove was cold. I got up and walked into the kitchen, expecting to see some trace of his presence, but there was nothing. No cup, no kettle, no footprints in the lingering dust. I told my mother about the man, but she dismissed it, saying it was probably just a dream from too much sugar.

I believed her, until a few weeks later, when my mother decided to make hot chocolate for the New Year. She swung the kettle off the stove, and as she poured the water into the cups, she noticed something: a small, black, soot-like mark on the stovetop, right where the man had placed his hand. It was a perfect handprint, with long fingers and a broad palm. She frowned and tried to wipe it away, but it wouldn’t come off. It stayed there for years, fading slowly, but never disappearing.

Eventually, we moved out of that house. I was in high school by then, and I had nearly forgotten the man at the stove. But last week, I received a letter from the new owner of our old house. They said they had found an old diary wedged behind the stove. It belonged to my great-grandfather, who had lived in that house before us. In it, he mentioned that his own father used to sneak down to the kitchen at night to make himself a cup of tea, because he said the stove was ‘good company.’ He described the same ritual, the same handle-turning. And he mentioned that his father had died in that kitchen, clutching the handle of the stove, on Christmas Eve, 1923.

The letter went on to say that the handprint on the stovetop matches the print left on the handle of the stove at the time of the death. I’d like to think that he’s just looking for a warm place, a survivor of a different time. But every night now, when I pass by my own small stove in my apartment, I can’t help but wonder: if I wait until the clock strikes two, will he come and turn the handle for me?

Related Horror Movies to Watch

⚡ WILLOW LIVE
Listening for whispers in the dark...
Real-Time Whispers Stream
REAL-TIME

Listening to the woods...