I never thought much about the little room behind the pantry. It was just there, a door we never opened, with a brass knob that had tarnished to a dull green. The realtor mentioned it once, ‘storage space,’ she’d said, and we’d shrugged, glad for the extra square footage without paying extra. My husband, Arun, jokingly called it the ‘time-out room’ when we first moved in, but we never really thought about it.
That changed on the first Tuesday of December, when I came home early with a migraine. The apartment was silent, the winter light slanting through the windows. I dropped my keys on the console and headed for the bedroom, but as I passed the pantry, I noticed the door to that room was slightly ajar. A thin line of darkness, like a cut. I frowned. We never opened that door. I was sure of it.
I pushed it open, expecting dust and old boxes. Instead, the room was bare except for a single wooden chair in the center, facing a small, round mirror on the wall. The mirror was old, its silver backing spotted with black, and it hung there as if waiting for something. A faint smell of camphor and old wood filled the air. I stepped back, confused. I’d never seen this before. The realtor’s ‘storage space’ was just an empty room with a chair and a mirror. I closed the door firmly, the click echoing in the hall.
That night, I told Arun about it. He laughed. ‘Maybe the landlord’s daughter used it for her art projects,’ he said. ‘But a chair and a mirror? That’s it?’ He shrugged. ‘I’ll check tomorrow.’ But he didn’t. We both forgot, or tried to. Yet, every time I passed the pantry, my eyes would drift to that door. And I began to notice the knob was always cold, no matter the room temperature, and the wood around it felt slightly damp.
A week later, I came home from work to find the door wide open. My heart thumped. I peered in. The chair was gone. The mirror was still there, but now it reflected not the empty room, but a hallway—a long, dark hallway with a single bulb swaying at the far end. I blinked, and it was just the bare white wall again. I slammed the door shut, my hands shaking. I called Arun, but he said he was stuck in traffic. ‘Calm down, just don’t go in there.’ Easy for him to say.
But the mirror stayed on my mind. I couldn’t stop thinking about it. At night, I’d lie awake, listening to the house settle, wondering if I’d heard the creak of that door. One night, I got up, heart pounding, and crept to the pantry. The door was closed. I put my hand on the knob. It was not just cold, it was freezing. I turned it, and the door swung open on its own.
The mirror was gone. In its place was a raw, dark hole in the wall, as if the wall had rotted away. And from the hole came a sound—a slow, rhythmic scratch, like something dragging its nails along wood. I wanted to run, but my feet were rooted. The scratching stopped. Then a voice, low and arid, like dead leaves, said, ‘You forgot me.’
I ran. I didn’t stop until I was in the bedroom, under the covers, shaking. When Arun came home, he found me there. ‘The room,’ I choked out. ‘There’s something in the room.’ He went to check. He came back, his face pale. ‘There’s nothing there,’ he said quietly. ‘Just an empty room.’ But he avoided my eyes.
We argued that night—not about the room, but about everything else. Little things turned big. I accused him of not believing me. He said I was imagining things. But the real horror came the next day. I came home to find the door open again, and this time, the mirror was back. But it wasn’t the same. In its reflection, I saw not the room, but a couple—a man and a woman—standing in a kitchen, arguing. The woman looked just like me. The man looked like Arun. And behind them, through a doorway, was that same dark hallway, and that same single bulb.
I screamed. I screamed until my throat was raw. Neighbors banged on the wall. I ran out of the apartment, into the street, and called Arun. ‘Get home now.’ When he arrived, he found me outside, crying. He held me, and I told him what I saw. This time, he didn’t dismiss me. He looked at the building with a strange fear. ‘We need to move,’ he said. ‘Today.’
We packed in a frenzy. We didn’t care about the deposit. We just wanted out. As we loaded the last box into the car, I saw the landlord’s face in the window of the ground floor apartment—he was watching us, his expression unreadable. I turned away.
We moved to a new flat on the other side of town. We never spoke of the room again. But sometimes, in the dead of night, I hear it—the slow, rhythmic scratch, coming from behind the wall, or inside the closet, or under the bed. And I know that the hole in the wall was not a door to another room. It was a mouth, and it had swallowed a part of me. And it was still chewing.
Arun started sleeping in the living room. He said he couldn’t stand my nightmares. But I know the truth. He saw what I saw. And he couldn’t face it. So I sit alone in the dark, listening. And waiting. Because I know, one day, I’ll find a door that shouldn’t be there, and I’ll have to open it. And this time, I won’t be able to close it again.