When I was nine, I became obsessed with old folklore and rural legends. Our farmhouse sat at the edge of a cornfield that stretched like a golden ocean to the horizon, and the nearest neighbor was a mile down a gravel road. I had read a tattered book, ‘Country Omens and Rural Signs,’ that claimed a person could glimpse their future spouse by standing before a still pond at the exact moment the full moon reached its zenith. But that required sneaking out, and I was too chicken for that. Instead, I fixated on a simpler charm: looking into a mirror at midnight on Halloween night would reveal the face of your true love. Or so the book said.
On Halloween night, my dad was away on a business trip, and my mom, who usually dismissed such things as silly, agreed to humor me. We stood in the upstairs bathroom, the only mirror in the house with a clear view of the hallway behind us. The lights were off, and I held a flashlight under my chin, but I was too scared to actually look. Mom laughed, ‘You go first, brave one.’ I shook my head, so she shrugged and looked into the mirror, her face serious for a moment, then she grinned. ‘I just see me. And you hiding behind my shoulder.’ I peeked, but saw only our reflections and the dim hallway stretching behind us. No ghostly visage. We went to bed, and I felt a bit foolish, though I still half-expected something to appear.
November came, bleak and gray, with dead leaves skittering across the yard. One evening, I was walking from my bedroom to the bathroom, my head down, kicking at the rug. I glanced up as I passed the bathroom doorway and saw the mirror at the end of the hall. In it, I saw my mother’s reflection. That wasn’t unusual—she might be in the bathroom—but the angle was wrong. She was standing at the kitchen sink, which was around the corner. I stopped and stared. The image was clear: her brown hair, her floral blouse, but her face was blank, like a mannequin. And behind her, in the mirror’s reflection, there was a shadowy figure, tall and thin, reaching towards her shoulders.
I blinked, and it was gone. The mirror showed only the hallway and the bathroom tile. I ran to the kitchen, my heart thumping. Mom was at the sink, rinsing a dish, humming. I asked, ‘Were you just in the bathroom?’ She turned, confused. ‘No, I’ve been here for ten minutes.’ I told her what I saw, but she laughed it off. ‘You’re still spooked from Halloween. Probably a trick of the light.’ But I couldn’t shake it. Over the next week, I began to see her reflection in mirrors more often, always in odd places: the hallway mirror when I knew she was in the basement, the living room mirror when she was outside. Each time, her reflection had that same blank stare, and behind her, the shadowy figure grew clearer. It was gaunt, with long fingers, and its mouth was open wide.
I started to avoid mirrors altogether. I taped paper over the bathroom mirror, but I could still see pieces of it. I told my mom, but she dismissed my fears. ‘You’re a sensitive kid, sweetie. Maybe you have a gift, but don’t let it scare you.’ Then, one night, I woke to a sound. It was a low hum, like a far-off motor. I got up, still half-asleep, and shuffled to the bathroom. I forgot I had uncovered the mirror to wash my face. As I leaned over the sink, I saw my own reflection, but it wasn’t me. It was me, but older, and my eyes were vacant. And behind me, the shadowy figure now had a face. It was mine. I screamed, and the figure in the mirror grinned.
My mom burst in, flicking on the light. The mirror showed only my terrified face. She held me, and I cried. In the following days, she noticed my distress and finally took me to see a doctor, who said I was an imaginative child. But the visions didn’t stop. I saw her reflection everywhere, even in windows and spoons. The figure behind her was always there, and now it was starting to turn its head towards me. One afternoon, I was in my room, and I saw my mother through the window, standing in the yard, looking at the house. But through the glass, her reflection was superimposed on the glass, and behind her, the figure was now holding a knife. I ran outside, and she was fine, but I couldn’t stop shaking.
I decided to confront the mirror. That night, I went to the bathroom, removed the paper, and stood before it. I didn’t call anyone. I just stared at my reflection. After a minute, my reflection began to change. It became my mother, but her smile was wrong. Behind her, the figure stepped out, and I saw it was my father. But my father was kind, not menacing. This version had sharp teeth and black eyes. I wanted to scream, but I couldn’t. The figure pointed at me, and then it mouthed, ‘She’s mine.’ I heard a crash from the kitchen. I ran, and my mom was on the floor, having slipped on a stray grape. She was laughing, but I saw her reflection in a knife on the counter: her face was contorted in a scream.
Finally, I couldn’t take it anymore. I took the mirror down from the wall and smashed it in the yard, burying the shards. But the following morning, there was a new mirror in the bathroom—my dad had bought it as a surprise. I walked past it, and saw my mother’s reflection, but this time, she was in the mirror, and I was in her place. She was walking towards me, holding my hand. I turned around, and she was gone, but the door to the basement was open. I knew I had to go down, or the reflection would never leave me.
I descended the creaking stairs, and in the dim light, there was a full-length mirror propped against the wall. In it, I saw my mother, but she was young, her hair long, and she was smiling. She spoke, ‘I’m so glad you helped me.’ I asked, ‘Helped you what?’ She said, ‘Choose.’ Then, the reflection reached out and pulled me into the glass. I felt cold metal, and then I was in the mirror, looking out at my mother, who was now in the real world, walking away. I screamed, but no sound came out. I’ve been trapped here ever since, watching my mother move on, and I know that one day, some other child will see my reflection and be tempted to help. And they’ll become my replacement.