The first time I noticed something was off was with the bread. I had just moved into my grandmother’s old farmhouse, a sprawling Victorian relic with peeling wallpaper and a furnace that groaned like a dying beast. It was late September, and the harvest had left the air thick with the smell of rotting apples. I was unpacking boxes in the kitchen when I saw it: a slice of bread on the counter, perfectly fresh that morning, now covered in a thin, gray fuzz. I hadn’t left it out. I never left bread out.
That evening, my brother Liam came in from the fields, stomping mud off his boots. He had this look, like he’d seen a ghost. ‘You won’t believe this,’ he said, his voice shaky. ‘I was walking up the path, and I swear I saw this little girl, maybe six, wearing a yellow raincoat and a floppy hat. She was standing right by the old well, just staring at me. Then she turned and walked through the side door into the kitchen, and then into the pantry. I checked, and there was no one there.’ I laughed it off, told him he was tired, but a cold chill ran down my spine. We had no well; it had been filled in decades ago.
The next morning, I was in the bathroom, the one with the cracked porcelain sink and a mirror that always fogged up. I was brushing my teeth when the light flickered—once, twice—then went out completely. I stood in the dark, my heart thumping, until it snapped back on. The reflection in the mirror was not mine. It was a flicker of a small, pale face with wide, dark eyes, topped with that same yellow hat. I blinked, and it was gone. I didn’t sleep well that night.
A week later, my best friend from the city, Maya, came to visit. We were in the living room, catching up over coffee, when my laptop, which was closed, suddenly slid across the table on its own. It stopped at the edge, teetering. Maya gasped. ‘Did you see that?’ I nodded, trying to play it cool. ‘It’s just the old floorboards, must be uneven.’ But I knew it wasn’t. That night, I heard scratching in the walls, like tiny claws. It followed me down the hallway.
The last straw was during dinner. We were all at the table—Liam, Maya, and I—eating a stew I’d made. The room went silent. Then, the salt shaker tipped over. Maya’s glass of water turned into a thin layer of ice. And in the corner of my eye, I saw the yellow raincoat flit past the doorway. I jumped up, but there was nothing there. Maya was pale. ‘We need to leave,’ she said. ‘Now.’
But I couldn’t leave. I had to know. I went into the attic, where my grandmother’s old trunk lay covered in dust. Inside, I found a photograph from 1952: a little girl, about six, wearing a yellow raincoat and a floppy hat, standing next to a well. My grandmother had a scrapbook with her name: Elsie, who had died of pneumonia that year. The entry said she was ‘drowned in the well.’ But the well was filled in, a concrete slab over it. Why would they fill in a well?
That night, I dug up the concrete slab in the backyard. My fingers bled, but I didn’t care. Underneath, I found a small, rusted locket. Inside was a lock of hair and a note: ‘Elsie, my sweet, forgive me.’ It was my grandfather’s handwriting. I dropped the locket into the void. The well was dry, but the air was cold. When I looked up, I saw her—Elsie, a translucent figure, now without her hat, her face twisted in rage. ‘You woke me,’ she hissed. ‘Now you must join me.’ The ground gave way, and I fell into the darkness.
I woke up in the hospital, three days later. They said I had fallen into a sinkhole. But I know the truth. And now, every time I see a yellow raincoat, I feel her watching. The farmhouse is quiet now, but the well is still there, and I know it’s only a matter of time before she finds someone else.