The drive from Birch Hollow to the coastal city of Marrow’s Point takes anywhere from fifty minutes to two hours, depending on the mood of the Turnpike and the weather. I left my apartment at 7:02, as usual, clutching a large iced oat milk latte with an extra shot of vanilla. The summer sun was already blearing over the spruce tops, promising another muggy day, but my car’s AC was set to freeze my knuckles as I tried to wake up.
I took the scenic route along the old river road, which cuts through the marshy lowlands before hitting the industrial zone. There’s a landmark I always use to gauge my progress: the abandoned cannery with its collapsed smokestack, just past the bridge over the Mud Creek. After that, it’s smooth sailing into the city’s outskirts. Or so I thought.
The radio was tuned to a talk show, the host droning about property taxes, but I wasn’t listening. My mind was on the pile of spreadsheets waiting on my desk. I took a long sip of my latte, letting the cold sweetness jolt my system. Just as I rounded the last bend before the cannery, I saw something that made the drink go down the wrong pipe.
A man was standing in the median, halfway between the two lanes, as if he’d been waiting for me. He wore a grey work shirt with a name tag I couldn’t read, and dark trousers that might have been black or navy. His hair was cropped close, almost military, and he was holding a clipboard against his chest like a shield. What chilled me wasn’t his presence, but the fact that he was completely still, facing my lane, his head tilted as if listening for something I couldn’t hear.
I swerved slightly, honking, but he didn’t flinch. He just stared through my windshield, his lips moving, forming words I couldn’t make out. Then I passed him, and in the rearview mirror, I saw him turn and walk across the opposite lane, between cars that seemed to slow just enough to miss him. A few drivers honked, but I saw no one stop to offer help. That was the first Sign that something was wrong.
The rest of the drive, I tried to shake it off. Probably a lost tourist or a mental health case. But by the time I reached the city limits, I noticed a pattern: at every intersection, there was a man in grey, standing on the corner, holding a clipboard, watching the cars. Same build, same short hair, same blank expression. They were like statues planted by the city, but they were moving—each one turned its head as I passed, tracking me.
I didn’t mention it to my coworkers. I figured I was just tired, sleep-deprived, the way I always was on mornings after I’d stayed up too late scrolling. But when I drove home that evening, the sun was lower, casting long shadows across the road, and there he was again—the same man from the morning, standing on the bridge over Mud Creek, this time without the clipboard. He was holding a small, white card in one hand, and as I slowed to take the curve, he raised it to his chest like a badge.
I don’t know why I did it, but I pulled over onto the shoulder. The bridge was empty except for him, and the wind off the creek was cold, carrying the smell of rot. He approached my car, his steps measured, and when he reached my window, he didn’t knock. He just placed the card on the glass and stepped back. The card was a business card, but the text was smeared, like it had been left in a puddle. I could make out a single line: ‘You are part of the proof. Report to the mill at daybreak.’
The mill. The old sawmill on the edge of town, the one with the decommissioned furnace that had been closed for decades. I’d passed it countless times, whatever. I tossed the card on the passenger seat and drove home, telling myself it was a prank, a misunderstanding, a trick of the light. But that night, as I lay in bed, I couldn’t shake the feeling that the man’s eyes had been the same pale blue as the frost that forms on car windows in winter, even though it was July.
The next morning, I took the main highway, avoiding the river road. But as I approached the city, I saw it again: a line of men in grey, spaced evenly along the guardrail, each holding a ladder, each pointing toward the sky. The radio crackled, and the talk show host said, ‘We now have confirmation that the construction of the new landfill will begin on schedule. As a reminder, all residents are encouraged to attend the opening ceremony. It will be held at the border of the old mill.’
My heart thudded. I hadn’t mentioned the mill to anyone. But the coincidence was too strong. On a whim, I took the exit for the old mill road, though I was running late. The road was empty, the asphalt cracked, and the mill’s smokestack rose like a tombstone against the hazy sky. In the parking lot, a cluster of grey-clad figures stood in a circle, and in the center was a pile of white cards, each one identical to the one on my seat.
I parked a safe distance away and watched. They didn’t move. They just stood there, as if waiting for a signal. I rolled down my window to hear better, and a voice came over the mill’s old PA system, scratchy but clear: ‘Day breaks, the line holds, the proof is gathered. Report to the center at noon.’
Then, as if on cue, the figures turned in unison and began to walk toward the mill’s gaping entrance, which had been sealed with plywood for years. I grabbed my phone to call the police, but the screen was black, even though I’d charged it overnight. The radio cut out, replaced by static, and in the static, I heard a whisper that wasn’t static: ‘You are the proof. You are the pen.’
I had to get out of there. I reversed, but my car stalled, and when I looked up, the men were gone, and a single figure stood at my window—the same man, but now his name tag was clearly visible: ‘Frost, Surveyor.’ He smiled, and his teeth were black, as if he’d been eating charcoal. ‘You brought the card,’ he said, his voice flat. ‘Welcome to the first day of the rest of your life.’
I floored it, leaving him in a cloud of dust, and drove straight to work. But when I arrived, the building was empty, the lights off, and a single white card was taped to the front door: ‘Stop. Turn back. The proof is complete.’
I never made it to Marrow’s Point again. My car ran out of gas on the highway, and I sat there, watching the sun climb, the miles of empty road stretching like a blank page. And I knew, with a certainty that chilled me to the bone, that the man in grey wasn’t waiting for me at work—he was waiting for me everywhere. And he had a pen in his hand, and my name was already on his list.