I moved into the old farmhouse on the edge of the marsh on a damp October afternoon. The real estate agent, a man named Mr. Harlow, had a nervous twitch and kept glancing at the upper windows as he handed over the keys. ‘Built in the ’20s, solid as they come,’ he said, but the way he cleared his throat made me wonder. The house smelled of dust and something faintly sweet, like rotten apples. My three animals—a border collie named Rex, a tabby named Whiskers, and a sleek black cat named Midnight—were uneasy from the start. Rex paced the hallways, his nails clicking on the worn hardwood, while the cats refused to leave the kitchen, staring at a spot on the wall where the plaster was cracked.
I had spent the last two weeks shuttling between the new place and my old apartment, rationalizing that I needed to clean the old place, but really, I was avoiding my first night. When I finally forced myself to stay, I didn’t sleep much. The house made noises—the settling of old bones, the wind in the eaves—and I chalked it up to age. I went to bed at eleven, with all three animals curled at my feet, and I drifted off with the faint sound of the marsh frogs.
I woke with a start. The glow of the digital clock read 3:00 AM. The room was pitch black, but I could feel the animals stirring. Rex jumped off the bed, his tail stiff, and let out a low whine. Whiskers and Midnight followed, their eyes glowing as they moved toward the door. Then, as if a switch had been hit, all three bolted up the stairs (I was on the ground floor, but the bedroom was upstairs, and they had been on the ground floor with me—I should have realized that was odd). They leaped onto the bed, pressing against me. Rex stood over me, one leg on each side of my torso, his head low, staring at the closed door. The cats huddled by my side, their fur bristling.
I lay there, heart hammering, trying to rationalize. Maybe a raccoon on the porch. But Rex’s staring was unnerving—he was poised, alert, as if guarding me from something on the other side. I whispered to him, ‘It’s okay, boy,’ but he didn’t move. I closed my eyes, trying to relax, but then I heard it: footsteps. Slow, deliberate, coming up the stairs. Each step creaked with the weight of a man. The footsteps stopped at the top, and then the bathroom door creaked open. The tap turned on—water ran. Then, a sound that made my blood run cold: a furious, rapid brushing, a frantic ‘shik-shik-shik-shik’ as if someone was scrubbing their teeth with a wire brush at impossible speed. It lasted about five seconds, then stopped.
The water turned off. Footsteps—now heavier, closer—approached my bedroom door. They stopped just outside. I held my breath, waiting. My animals were frozen, and Rex’s low growl was a vibration in his chest. Then, without warning, a loud thud rang out from the middle of the room, as if something heavy had been dropped. Rex snapped his head toward the sound, still standing guard. I saw nothing.
I lay there, terrified, until dawn. When the first gray light seeped through the curtains, the animals relaxed. Rex let out a sigh and collapsed beside me, exhausted. I got up, my legs shaky, and checked the bathroom. The sink was wet, the toilet seat up. There was a toothbrush on the floor—an old, worn-out toothbrush I had never used, with bristles splayed and worn down, as if someone had brushed with it for hours in a frenzy. I didn’t stay another night. I called Mr. Harlow from my car, and I told him I was breaking the lease. He didn’t argue. He just sighed and said, ‘It’s been quiet for a while. I hoped it would stay that way. I’m sorry.’
Later, I learned from a neighbor that the previous tenant had been a dental hygienist who went mad in the house, and one night, in the bathroom, she brushed her teeth until her gums bled, and then she never came out. The house had been empty for years. But I knew better than to ask what she was doing with that toothbrush. Some things are better left in the dark, and I’ve never heard that sound again—except sometimes, in my dreams, I hear that furious brushing, and I know that if I ever go back, it will be waiting for me, just past the door.