I was about three years old when this happened, though the memory is more my mother’s than mine. She tells it like this: we were in the kitchen of our small apartment, the one with the peeling linoleum and the window that looked out onto the fire escape. I was sitting on the counter, kicking my legs, when I suddenly went still. My eyes fixed on the doorway that led to the hallway. I remember the way the light from the living room cast a long, distorted shape across the floor, but my mother saw nothing. I reached out, grabbed her hand, and pointed. ‘Mamá, ¿quién es él? ¿Quién?’ I asked, my voice insistent. She told me there was no one there, but I kept staring, my little face serious. She tried to distract me, but for the rest of the day, I kept looking back at that empty doorway as if I expected someone to walk through.
Years passed, and I had almost forgotten about that moment until a few months ago. My mother still babysits, and one afternoon, she was watching her friend’s daughter, a three-year-old named Sofia. The girl’s mother had come to drop her off because there was a funeral that day—her own grandfather’s, who had passed away the week before. I was home visiting, and I walked into the kitchen to get a glass of water. Sofia was playing on the floor with some blocks, but as I passed her, she looked up, her eyes widening. She scrambled to her feet and grabbed my wrist with surprising strength. Her tiny fingers dug into my skin as she pointed toward the hallway, the same doorway I had stared at all those years ago. ‘Marnie, who is that?’ she asked, her voice calm but urgent. I felt a cold dread wash over me. I turned to look, but I saw nothing. The hallway was empty, the same old doorway, the same light. But Sofia wouldn’t let go. She kept asking, ‘Who is that? He’s looking at you.’ She described a man in a dusty brown suit, standing just out of the light, his face unreadable. I asked her what he was doing, and she whispered, ‘He’s waiting. He says he’s been waiting for you.’
That night, I couldn’t sleep. I lay in my childhood bed, staring at the doorway to my old room, expecting to see that same figure. I thought about my mother’s grandfather, the one who died when I was twelve days old. I never knew him, but I’d heard stories: he was a tall, quiet man who liked to sit by the window and watch the street. He had a habit of standing in doorways, just watching. My grandmother said he always seemed to be waiting for something, but he never told anyone what. And now, Sofia’s question echoed in my mind: ‘Who is that?’ Maybe he wasn’t waiting for a person. Maybe he was waiting for me to see him, to acknowledge that he was there. But why? I didn’t have an answer.
The next morning, I asked my mother if she remembered the day I pointed at the doorway. She nodded, her face pale. ‘I tried to forget that,’ she said. ‘You were so insistent, and later you told me that the man at the door was angry because I couldn’t see him. You said he was your great-grandfather, and he was upset that he’d missed you.’ I felt a chill. I had no memory of saying that, but it felt true. Since then, I’ve started to notice doorways more, always checking the shadows. Sometimes, out of the corner of my eye, I think I see a man in a brown suit, but when I turn, he’s gone. And I wonder if he’s still waiting, or if he’s finally decided to step through.