Ever since I moved into the old farmhouse on the edge of Cinderwood, I’d had this nagging sense of being watched. Not the paranoid kind, just a prickling at the back of my neck when I was alone in the house. Last week, it got worse. I was in the pantry, looking for a jar of pickles on the bottom shelf, and the door—a heavy oak thing that always swung shut—had been propped open with a chair. As I crouched down, the chair legs scraped and the door began to swing closed, slowly, as if someone were leaning against it. I pushed it back with my shoulder and snapped, “Enough! Leave me be!” The resistance vanished, and the door settled into place. I felt a strange relief, and the watcher’s presence seemed to fade.
That night, as I lay in bed in the attic bedroom, the feeling returned, stronger. The room was small, with a single dormer window and a sloped ceiling. I checked the corners, under the bed, even in the closet—empty. I got back under the covers, pulling the blanket up to my chin. The weight of eyes pressed on me, so I turned to face the wall and yanked the blanket over my head. At some point, I drifted off, but I woke to a profound cold. The room was dark, and the shadows in the far corner were moving, not like a flicker, but like they were gathering, thickening. My breath fogged. I reached for the blanket, and as I pulled it up, a stream of icy air breathed across my cheek, smelling of mothballs and damp earth. I froze, and I heard a soft creak, like someone stepping on an old floorboard. The shadows congealed into a shape, tall and thin, with arms that ended in long fingers. It took a step, and the floorboards groaned.
“I told you to leave!” I shouted, but my voice came out as a whisper. The thing tilted its head, and I saw it had no face, just a smooth dark oval. It raised a hand, and the fingers stretched toward me. I scrambled back against the headboard, the blanket clutched to my chest. The cold air grew bitter, frosting the window. I felt a presence in my mind, a pressure, and I knew it was angry. It didn’t want to leave. It had been there longer than I had. It had claimed this house, and I was the intruder.
I remembered the old rumors about the previous owner, a reclusive spinster named Agnes who had died in this very room. They said she’d boarded up the attic to keep something out, but I’d unsealed it when I moved in. I looked at the corner where the shadows were thickest, and I saw a patch of wall that was newer, where the wood was lighter. I scrambled out of bed and tore at the boards, my fingers bleeding, until a small cavity was exposed. Inside, I found a child’s toy—a small, wooden horse with a broken leg—and a photograph of a young woman with hollow eyes. As I touched it, the room grew deathly silent. The shape in the corner dissolved, and the cold lifted. I heard a sigh, like a final breath, and then nothing.
I left the house the next morning and never returned. But sometimes, when I’m alone in my apartment, I catch a whiff of mothballs, and I know that wherever I go, the door I opened in that attic was never meant to be closed again. And I can feel a cool breath on my cheek, even when no one is there.